Global Energy Policies and Crop Price Volatility

Energy policies are driving up farming costs and food prices. Here's how:

• Energy Costs Impact Farming: Rising oil prices increase fuel, fertilizer, and electricity costs, making farming more expensive. A 1% rise in oil prices can increase food prices by 0.2%.
• Biofuel Mandates Shift Crop Use: Policies like the U.S. Renewable Fuel Standard redirect crops like corn and soybeans to biofuel production, raising food prices (e.g., corn prices up 30%, soybean prices up 20%).
• Carbon Taxes Add Costs: Carbon costs can raise crop production expenses by up to 32.6% for corn, impacting exports and affordability.
• Clean Energy Challenges: Transitioning to renewable energy can cut farm costs but requires high initial investments, with mixed results for farmers.

Energy Policy Effect	Impact on Agriculture
Oil price increases	Higher fuel, fertilizer, and food prices
Biofuel mandates	Increased crop prices, reduced food supply
Carbon pricing	Higher production costs, reduced exports
Renewable energy adoption	Lower long-term costs but high upfront investment

This growing link between energy and agriculture demands coordinated policies to balance food security, energy goals, and market stability.

Biofuels scandal + food prices

Current Energy Policy Changes

Global energy policies are shifting, and these changes are having a direct impact on agricultural markets. These developments influence everything from production costs to crop prices, creating challenges and opportunities for the farming sector.

Clean Energy Adoption

Investments in renewable energy are helping some farmers cut operating costs significantly. For example, Sandra Jefford, a dairy farmer in Gippsland, Australia, managed to slash her irrigation energy costs from $80,000 to $12,000 annually after investing $1 million in renewable energy systems in 2022.

However, the transition to clean energy isn't without its hurdles. Dairy farmers, on average, spend roughly $26,000 annually on shed electricity. A 30% increase in energy costs can be especially tough for operations with annual bills exceeding $100,000. Mark Billing, President of United Dairy Farmers of Victoria, emphasizes the challenges:

"A 30 per cent increase in anything is significant and dairy farmers are completely reliant on power to harvest the milk and more particularly cooling the milk."

These clean energy policies are also evolving alongside biofuel mandates, which are reshaping crop markets.

Biofuel Rules

Biofuel mandates are changing how crops are allocated and priced. In the U.S., 36% of corn production is now used for bioethanol, while global biofuel consumption reached 126 billion liters in 2021.

Here’s how crop usage is distributed globally:

• 22% of sugarcane production goes to ethanol.
• 16% of maize is used for ethanol.
• 15% of vegetable oil is directed to biodiesel.

The EPA has found that for every billion gallons of ethanol required by the Renewable Fuel Standard, corn prices rise by 2–3%. Overall, ethanol blending mandates have increased corn prices by 30%, while biofuel policies have driven soybean prices up by 20%.

Carbon Costs

Carbon taxes are adding to production costs, with some crops being hit harder than others:

Crop	Maximum Cost Increase at $144/ton CO2-e
Corn	32.6%
Soybeans	22.4%

These costs also affect U.S. exports. Corn exports drop by 24.9%, sorghum by 20.5%, and wheat by 8.7%. On the other hand, exports of barley, soybeans, and sunflower see a slight increase of 1.2–8.8%.

Tania Chapman, Executive General Manager of Farming Operations at Nutrano Produce Group, underscores the difficulties:

"We are being hit from every angle and I actually don't see a way forward for fresh produce, unless we start to look at other ways we can reduce some of those inputs."

Carbon pricing has expanded dramatically. In 2014, it covered just 12% of greenhouse gas emissions at $7 per tonne. Today, it covers 23% of emissions at $32 per tonne.

Energy Policy Effects on Crop Prices

Farm Energy Costs

Rising carbon prices lead to higher fuel and electricity expenses for farms, increasing costs at every stage of production. These added expenses often push farmers to focus on planting higher-value biofuel crops, adjusting their land use accordingly.

Land Use Changes

As energy costs climb, farmers increasingly prioritize biofuel crops over others. For instance, U.S. corn acreage rose from 78 million acres in the early 2000s to about 91 million acres annually. By 2023, nearly 50% of soybean oil production was used for biofuels, with the other half going toward food production. Studies suggest that a 20% rise in soybean oil demand for biofuels could increase retail prices of oil-based food products by anywhere from 0.16% to 4.41%.

"Research continues to support our industry philosophy that U.S. Soy has the unique ability to solve two existential challenges: food security and renewable energy. Further, this study shows the increase in biofuels has had limited impact on inflation at the grocery store".

These changes in land use not only affect local farming practices but also have a ripple effect on global market trading dynamics.

Market Trading Effects

The combined influence of rising costs and shifting land use patterns is now evident in market trading. Geoeconomic fragmentation could further amplify commodity price volatility, leaving low-income countries particularly vulnerable. Projections suggest these nations could face long-term GDP losses averaging 1.2% due to disruptions in agricultural imports.

In 2023, global carbon pricing revenues hit a record $104 billion, with over half directed toward climate and nature-focused initiatives. As noted by World Bank Senior Managing Director Axel van Trotsenburg:

"Carbon pricing can be one of the most powerful tools to help countries reduce emissions... This report can help expand the knowledge base for policymakers to understand what is working and why both coverage and pricing need to go up for emissions to go down".

sbb-itb-a92d0a3

Policy Examples and Results

This section highlights how shifts in energy policies directly affect agricultural commodity prices.

EU Biofuel Requirements

The European Union's Renewable Energy Directive (RED) has played a major role in shaping agricultural commodity markets, particularly vegetable oil prices. Back in the late 2000s, the EU was responsible for around 75% of global biodiesel consumption. However, that figure has dropped to about 36% in recent years. Today, around 73% of biodiesel production depends on vegetable oils, including 24% soybean oil, 14% rapeseed oil, and 31% palm oil.

In 2022, disruptions in sunflower oil imports from Ukraine led several EU member states to cut back on biofuel production from traditional feedstocks. This move aimed to control skyrocketing vegetable oil prices, showing the fine line between meeting renewable energy goals and addressing food security concerns.

US Corn-Ethanol Program

The U.S. corn-ethanol program has seen dramatic growth since 2000. Ethanol production surged by over 700% between 2000 and 2012, with the share of corn used for ethanol rising from less than 10% to more than 40%. Bruce A. Babcock, an economics professor at Iowa State University, explained the connection between ethanol production and food costs:

"It is disingenuous to argue that there is no link between ethanol production and corn prices. And there is a direct link between higher corn prices and food costs because higher corn prices translate directly into higher feed costs, which eventually translate into higher prices for meat, eggs, and dairy products."

From 2006 to 2009, ethanol expansion added about $0.45 per bushel to corn prices, accounting for roughly 27% of the total price increase during that time. A meta-analysis predicted that a one-billion-gallon expansion of the U.S. corn ethanol mandate in 2015 would result in a 3–4% rise in corn prices. These trends have led to varying fuel price impacts, especially in developing economies.

Fuel Price Changes in Developing Markets

Fuel price shifts in developing markets often create long-term pressure on food costs. For lower-income households, food can make up as much as 55% of total spending, compared to about 33% for wealthier households. While wealthier nations might feel a sharper initial impact from fuel price shocks, the effects tend to last longer in developing economies.

Fuel taxation also differs significantly between regions. For example, by June 2021, fuel taxes in the EU made up about 60% of retail gasoline prices, while in the U.S., they accounted for less than 20%. These variations further shape the economic pressures faced by different countries.

Next Steps and Future Changes

Energy Goals vs Food Supply

Clean energy initiatives now account for 40%-50% of variable cropping costs in advanced economies. This creates a tough balancing act for policymakers. As fossil fuel use is expected to drop from 78% of global energy demand in 2023 to around 40%-60% by 2050, energy and agricultural planning must work hand in hand to ensure stable food production.

"The clean energy transition will also need to be balanced with affordability, energy system resiliency, and energy security in an increasingly uncertain macroeconomic environment."

Combined Energy-Farm Planning

Fertilizer prices have tripled since 2020, driven by a heavy reliance - 70%-80% - on natural gas for ammonia and urea production. This highlights the need for better coordination between energy and farming systems. Many smaller farms in the U.S. have started using renewable energy, which helps them avoid price swings while contributing to clean energy efforts. The strong link between oil and crop prices (r = 0.78) further emphasizes the importance of this approach.

Impact Area	Challenge	Solution
Production Costs	Energy makes up 6% of farm costs	Invest in renewable energy systems
Market Stability	71% of farms in "critical zone"	Provide emergency support programs
Environmental Goals	High reliance on fossil fuels	Encourage clean energy adoption

Better integration of energy and agriculture could also help manage costs more strategically.

Price Control Methods

The International Energy Agency suggests several ways to address price challenges:

• Short-term Actions
  • Lift restrictions on fertilizer trade
  • Provide emergency loans to offset energy costs
  • Offer incentives for efficient nutrient use
• Long-term Solutions
  • Shift to low-carbon ammonia production
  • Develop energy-efficient crop systems
  • Establish price supports for at-risk populations

One example of effective policy is conservation tillage. By 2000, U.S. farmers had implemented this method on over 109 million acres, or 36% of planted cropland - up from 26% in 1990. This shows how well-designed incentives can drive change without sacrificing productivity.

Market Data Tools

With global energy policies causing shifts in commodity prices, having advanced tools to track and manage these changes is more important than ever.

OilpriceAPI Features

OilpriceAPI delivers updates every 5 minutes for Brent Crude, WTI, and Natural Gas. This allows analysts to quickly assess how oil price changes - responsible for 20–40% of agricultural price fluctuations - impact crop costs. For example, when crude oil prices soared from $76 per barrel in January 2022 to over $110 in March 2022 due to geopolitical tensions, analysts used this data to predict farming input costs and crop price trends.

Data Feature	Analysis Benefit	Market Impact
Real-time Updates	Immediate assessment of policy effects	Faster response to market changes
Historical Records	Long-term trend evaluation	Improved forecasting accuracy
Multi-commodity Coverage	Cross-market correlation insights	Broader risk analysis

These features enable more comprehensive market evaluations and decision-making.

API Market Analysis

APIs have become indispensable for managing market volatility, especially as energy demand is expected to grow by 37% over the next 25 years. API-driven tools provide the precision needed for agricultural market analysis during unpredictable times.

The link between energy and agriculture prices was evident during recent disruptions. For instance, Brent crude rose from $41.96 per barrel in 2020 to $107.64 in July 2022. During such events, API-powered systems helped traders and analysts:

1. Track Market Dynamics and Predict Trends
   • Real-time data highlights how energy policies directly influence agricultural costs.
   • In February, the energy price index fell by 4.2%, with coal prices dropping 9.8% and crude oil falling 5.6%.
   • Integrated datasets support forecasting models that consider factors like weather, geopolitics, and biofuel demand.
2. Manage Risk Effectively
   • Access to timely, accurate data strengthens hedging strategies and risk management.
   • Correlation analysis helps identify vulnerabilities during major events, such as the Global Financial Crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic.

APIs are reshaping how analysts navigate complex market landscapes, offering tools to stay ahead in volatile conditions.

Conclusion

Key Insights

Energy policies have a direct impact on agricultural prices. In countries like the United States, energy costs account for 40–50% of variable cropping expenses. Rising costs for inputs are worsening food security challenges, with the number of people facing acute food insecurity expected to grow by 17%, reaching 323 million by 2024. These figures highlight the critical need to analyze future market trends.

Impact Area	Current Status	Future Outlook
Food Costs	$15,656 per year for an average US family (2023)	5.8% projected increase
Price Correlation	0.63 correlation between corn and oil (2006–2023)	Growing interdependence

Moving Forward

As discussed earlier, shifts in policies and market dynamics are transforming agricultural pricing. By 2023, nearly half of soybean oil production was allocated to biofuel manufacturing. This trend underscores the strengthening connection between energy and crop prices, demanding immediate strategic action.

"Higher energy prices mean higher farming, ranching and transportation costs that cause the price of food and groceries prices to rise, taking more money out of family pockets. It is an inescapable, iron law of consumer prices that policymakers ignore at their own – and American families' – peril."
– Chris Ventura, CEA Midwest Director

To address these challenges, stakeholders should focus on:

• Strengthening international collaboration on energy and food security
• Establishing support systems for at-risk populations
• Optimizing nutrient use in agricultural practices
• Expanding renewable energy use across the food supply chain

The agricultural sector’s ability to navigate these evolving challenges will be critical for ensuring stable food supplies while managing the pressures from shifting energy policies.